Blog Home

«
»

Oregon’s Medicaid Experiment: Coverage Is The First Step



May 2nd, 2013
by John Lumpkin

As a longtime physician, I know that having access to stable, affordable health coverage is a critical step in achieving better health outcomes.

That view is underscored in a study that appeared in today’s (May 2) New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) on the effects of Medicaid coverage on individuals’ health and finances. Led by researchers at Harvard and MIT, the study—the Oregon Health Insurance Study—offers a good snapshot of how being insured can help low-income Americans.

Here’s the background:  In 2008, Oregon officials created a lottery giving uninsured, low-income adults a chance to apply for Medicaid. Nearly 90,000 people signed up, and approximately 30,000 were selected. By randomly providing health insurance to some, but not all, Oregon effectively established both treatment and control groups, presenting a unique opportunity to analyze the effects of having public health insurance.

The study in NEJM highlighted the latest data from the experiment. It showed that enrollment in Medicaid, after about two years, profoundly increased patients’ use of needed medical services, and vastly reduced the financial strain that previously limited their care.

The use of physician services, prescription drugs and hospitalizations increased by about 35 percent when patients had Medicaid. The probability of having a consistent place to get care, and to receive preventive services and screenings, increased by 50 percent or more.

Having Medicaid had a big impact on family finances. It virtually eliminated out-of-pocket catastrophic medical expenditures for enrolled individuals. It alleviated other measures of financial strain, such as reducing by more than 50 percent the probability of having to borrow money, or having to skip paying other bills because of medical expenses.

One of the most significant findings is that expanding Medicaid was shown to substantially reduce depression. Those who received Medicaid in the Oregon lottery reduced rates of depression by a noteworthy 30 percent compared to those who did not have coverage. This is important, because improving mental health is a powerful gateway to improving overall health.

Each of these factors demonstrates the value of health insurance coverage, but the study’s findings show that coverage alone will not necessarily lead to good health. Over two years, those who received Medicaid through the lottery were more likely to be diagnosed with diabetes than those who were uninsured, but their blood sugar levels remained about the same. The same was true for their blood pressure and cholesterol levels.

Coordinating care for complex illness—as well as adhering to new medications and reversing the effects of detrimental lifestyle choices—are all difficult to accomplish, regardless of a patient’s insurance status. Providers and patients, and our health system as a whole, must do a better job navigating these thorny issues. Various efforts are underway to improve care for those with chronic illnesses. We also know that these conditions are affected by factors unrelated to health care, such as where people live, their income and their education.

The bottom line is that better health requires health insurance coverage, but it doesn’t end there.

So far, the Oregon Health Insurance Study shows us that people who obtained Medicaid coverage received more health care services in the first two years—especially needed preventive care—and had less depression and financial worries. Their health outcomes weren’t significantly better, but at least they are now participating in the health care system and getting the care they need, without plunging their families deeper into poverty. From this vantage point, the glass seems more than half full.

Email This Post Email This Post Print This Post Print This Post

Don't miss the insightful policy recommendations and thought-provoking research findings published in Health Affairs.

1 Trackback for “Oregon’s Medicaid Experiment: Coverage Is The First Step”

  1. CEO Post: Response to Oregon Medicaid Study | REACH Healthcare Foundation
    May 13th, 2013 at 12:08 pm

2 Responses to “Oregon’s Medicaid Experiment: Coverage Is The First Step”

  1. rbialek Says:

    Certainly health insurance coverage is an important step. It will be interesting to see how the Oregon “experiment” continues to evolve with their formation of Coordinated Care Organizations (Oregon’s version of the Accountable Care Organization). These CCOs recognize the need to integrate population health strategies and state and local health departments into their operations. Health insurance combined with exceptional population health/public health interventions may very well be the recipe for improving quality and community and individual health, and controlling healthcare costs.

  2. Jeff Goldsmith Says:

    John,

    What are we, American society, buying, exactly, for $2.8 trillion a year? Protection from the effects of the $2.8 trillion cost on our household budgets, a somewhat lighter mood, a lot of (mostly) well paying jobs and . . . what else? What’ s the societal ROI here?

    As a lifetime advocate of reducing health disparities, it’s hard to imagine that you can feel good about this study. . .

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is in use. Please do not submit your comment twice -- it will appear shortly.

Authors: Click here to submit a post.