January 30th, 2015
In a recent post, we agreed with Goetzel et al. about the advisability of moving away from a preoccupation with the return-on-investment (ROI) of wellness programs and toward the more systemic, iterative view required to make progress toward workplace “cultures of health.”
At the same time, we acknowledged Lewis et al. and others for helping to usher in a new and needed scrutiny of the fairness and effectiveness of employment-based wellness programs. But, we also cited peer-reviewed evidence that counters Lewis et al.’s conclusion that there are no conditions under which employer wellness programs, and by extension employer efforts to manage their core health-related value/sustainability challenge, can achieve a return-on-investment (ROI) ratio of better than 1-to-1 savings to cost.
Lewis et al. have added their voice to the scrutiny increasingly applied to employer use of outcome-triggered incentives or penalties to promote employee behavior change in the context of health-contingent programs under financial provisions in the Affordable Care Act. The momentum fueling these developments could soon extend far beyond wellness programs.Read the rest of this entry »